Today, I saw Professor Yehuda Baruch from the University of East Anglia at Norwich run a workshop called Opening the black box of academic reviewing and editing. The session was jointly hosted by the department of Management and International Business and the department of Psychology.
It was a most informative session, so much so that subsequently, I got his book out of the library:
Winning reviews: A guide for evaluating scholarly writing. (2006). (p. 262). Houndmills, Basingstoke, Hampshire: Palgrave Macmillan.
As much as the workshop was useful the book is even better. If I get some time, I’ll summarise the ideas-here.